Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Reflections of our community
The White Lake Mirror
Your locally owned & operated, nonprofit news source.
Subscribe
Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026
The White Lake Mirror

WLGC members, board address noise complaints at Fruitland Twp. meeting; residents question treasurer on audit issues

WHITEHALL — Over 50 Fruitland Township residents attended Monday's regular township board meeting, primarily members of the White Lake Golf Club addressing dissatisfaction with the handling of noise complaint enforcement against the golf course. The noise complaint was discussed among township trustees in August, when discussion revolved around two complaints made against the golf course - located at the corner of Scenic and South Shore drives - regarding course maintenance during quiet hours before 7 a.m. If the township’s ordinance enforcement determined the golf course to be in violation of the noise ordinance, the township would proceed with citation and then legal action if the WLGC did not adhere to the ordinance.
As of November, a court date was being rescheduled between the township and WLGC, and with that item on the agenda, 15 separate residents took to public comment to provide context for the situation on the side of the WLGC. Some of that context included the information that the primary complainant had lived at their property for nearly 30 years with no previous known complaints to the township, nor had other complaints been levied against the club in its 110 years of operation, especially in the several decades since the current maintenance routine has been established. Comments also stated that these maintenance practices and times are standard across golf courses worldwide, and could prove financially disruptive should the club not be able to begin their tee times promptly at 7 a.m. Board members of the club who spoke also shared that WLGC has taken steps to mitigate the disruption for the primary complainant as much as possible, to no avail. Also discussed was the language of the ordinance, which many considered vague and not specifically restrictive for routine maintenance work.
All comments asked for the board to dismiss litigation against the club, with club president Ryan Briegel specifically requesting that “the township drop this citation from civil proceedings… and avoid further unnecessary expenditure of money and time by both parties.” Briegal also handed the township clerk a Freedom of Information Act request for “all citations and [noise] complaints for the last five years that the township had seen.”
The rescheduling of the new court date for the citation against WLGC and the public comment earlier in the meeting prompted Trustee Brent Brauer to request further discussion of the item, with Brauer further requesting the enforcement officers reports and the complaints for the board to reference. Brauer also agreed with several public comments that the ordinance was indeed vague and asked if the board had the option to postpone the rescheduled court date. The board unanimously approved a motion to postpone the court date for 60 days until the conflict is further investigated.
Several other public comments responded to developments regarding the township’s recent deficient financial audit, and the thousands of dollars spent correcting mistakes made by and providing education to Treasurer Justin Roggero. Comments asked for the treasurer to take accountability for the deficiencies and requested frequent check-ins for assurances the accounting is being handled properly and in a timely manner.
Roggero, who’d been working with the board to correct the deficiencies in bookkeeping since August, admitted that “there’s been struggles. I definitely think that there have been some pitfalls, especially when I took office, that I don’t feel like were as much inherently my issues. [But] it has been a recurring theme, I will say that. I will take accountability from that.”
Roggero also informed the board and attendees that he believed the township’s investments over the past year have recuperated was what recently spent, but also said, “I definitely am not saying that the good that we have done in any way, shape or form validates that or makes [the loss] okay… any loss of taxpayer funds is not to be taken lightly.”
When asked by a resident if he felt qualified for the job, Roggero responded that, upon his initial application to the position - he was the only applicant - he felt his personal bookkeeping and investments were sound, but he had underestimated the work needed to do the job and was confronted with a “steep learning curve” regarding the BS&A accounting software. When further asked if he should consider stepping down, Roggero replied he did not think that was responsible to the township as they would not be able to get another treasurer in time before tax bills were submitted, and resigning would most likely guarantee the township would have to spend further funds to hire outside help with that task.
Roggero did say that if, once the taxes were complete and if issues recurred, he would step down rather than be recalled by the township.
Of his recent education and his confidence to further serve as treasurer, Roggero said, “I do feel like I do have a pretty good understanding, especially given the amount of time and effort that has been poured into me over the last seven months in this process.”
The most recent update in total expenses managing the audit deficiencies amounted to $10,390.59.
The township unanimously approved the request by the parks commission to rename Nestrom Park to Robert P. Murray Park in honor of the former commission chair, who passed away from cancer in October. Marcinkowski said of Murray that no one had “dedicated more time, effort and [their] own money into restoring the park and bringing the park up to the standard which it's getting to be.” He further credited Murray with recent additions to the park including restrooms, tennis and pickleball courts, accessible pathways, road reconstructions and trails.
A replacement for Murray’s now vacant seat was also made by the board, with Marcinkowski proposing Guy Reece, a long-time township resident who was involved in the Tranquil Trail road project as a liaison between the planning commission and residents. This proposal was unanimously approved.
Finally, the board unanimously approved a resolution to approve the Muskegon County Road Commission’s quote of $46,000 to repave the Scenic Drive road end for 2027. This is a significant decrease from the initial quote earlier in the year, which was for $71,000. Considering the section is heavily utilized by residents and tourists outside of those residing on the road-end, the township will adjust the fund split accordingly, with 25% cost to the MCRC, 25% to the road end residents and 50% to the township.